5 Miles is very far, except for possibly long reach (sub 1ghz) 5G, which is lower capacity but still typically pretty decent.
Yeah I would assume at those speeds, any throttling wouldn’t be noticeable, the throttle is likely higher, I think you were seeing like 30/10 or something at home, so since you’re below that it shouldn’t impact you.
No comment.
If they’re anything like T-Mobile, they’re giving their wireless internet the lowest QOS priority, so even people with “de prioritized” MVNO cellular service get priority over your internet. So when a lot of people are using their phones, it will impact you. Of course if you had a fast 5G signal it would be a lot less impact.
Odd, that implies that either they have a 5G antenna closer to you that maybe they’re in the process of installing/upgrading (fingers crossed) or that there is a long reach 5G signal on those far away antennas that for some reason the modem does not want to stay connected to. Have you tried putting the Nokia up as high as you can for testing, (heck could even try putting it out a couple windows just to see). It is possible that it thinks the 4G signal is better due to being a higher frequency/capacity band, even though the signal strength is worse. Sort of like when a wifi device insists on sticking to a band that is slower. If you can’t get it to lock on to 5G again, then maybe you’re going to have 5G there soon when then finish the tower (sometimes the map gets updated before the actual service). Do you have a phone through them (or whomever they use for cellular, not sure if they have their own or are reselling someone else), does it show 5G?
Curious if you tested via the Eero during that hour and saw if it was being throttled, since those speeds are above what you were seeing get throttled before.
Do you mean the second “modem” he keeps referring to? That’s just a router, no different than your Eero. It is odd that he is seeing faster speeds on that where you were seeing it throttled, but maybe that video is from before the firmware that added the throttling? It says 1 year ago and I think the threads we saw about throttling being added were from earlier this year? He also mentions it is a gen 1 gateway and that there is now gen 3, not sure which you have, maybe the firmware is different and one has the throttling. Not surprising he’s seeing better wifi speeds on an external router, we know the wifi in these gateways is never all that great.
Well you probably won’t notice any throttling at those speeds, but need to look at the resolution and see if they’re down sampling it. When that happens I believe the app will still say “1080P” or “HD” because as far as it knows, that’s the stream it is pulling. But I’ve never tried it across anything that down samples so not positive. I’m assuming you’d know if it was 480P, but 720P can be hard to differentiate from 1080 depending on the screen size. But if it looks good, doesn’t really matter all that much. If your Plex server or home internet router has a bandwidth meter (and if you have one on the Eero or on a PC) you could compare the two to see if it is identical on the sending and receiving side.
Even if you can’t get it to stick to 5G and the higher speeds, relocating the Nokia might at least get you a bit faster speed on 4G and hopefully even reduce the impact of that “rush hour” slow down you’re seeing. But personally once I knew it was possible to connect to 5G, I’d be searching for a spot that it can lock onto that
Might even be worth a (sigh) call to their support to see if there is anything they can tweak in the Nokia or if they know that a new tower is coming online, etc.
Could just be total coincidence, maybe there is 5G there and has been, but they’re doing maintenance on the tower or something. That’s exactly what is happening at my house, the antenna down the road is down for upgrades (I can see them swapping the antennas and wiring) so I’m connected with only 2 bars to a more distant tower.
The varying speed sucks but it definitely seems the better of two turds (and much cheaper to boot). And hopefully it will be able to get 5G and then be significantly better.