An update regarding Person Detection

Well, that’s really a separate issue. Ideally, it shouldn’t trigger on a dog at all, but the AI isn’t perfect. I was just out of town for about a week, and I got 3 “Person detection” notifications while I was gone. One was a FedEx lady. One was a random shadow. One was a cat. So, two false positives in a week of recording. Not bad, but not perfect. If they implement more smart AI triggers later (animals, vehicles, etc) I would also hope that you’ll be able to pick and choose which ones to use per camera.

Yeah, you have to careful who your partner with, and how you partner with them - and read the contract!!. Now you are getting divorced, since it allowed for that in the prenup. Thanks for the disclosure. Edge refers to “edge detection” which has been around for 40+ years. The point of what Xnor.ai did was to take public domain software and downsize the program to app size so it would work on a small (and low power draw) SoC which you have in your cameras and does not require the computers in the cloud (AWS?). I presume that you are working on the “downsizing” like they did, and as is usual for pioneer software there is not timeline for this (other than the usual ASAP). If you have to go to the cloud for a temporary measure please make it you own cloud to keep up with your ethics to date (great ones) so that you can control the privacy/security with full end to end encryption - so no “stealing of data”; like Ring. Full disclosure.

I think you have it backwards. The existence of great value V2’s was made possible by the existence of a good wifi infrastructure not the other way round. A can have a great Tesla because of I-5. But the condition of I-5 does impact on the benefit of driving a Tesla: no question.

Wyze is a value product BECAUSE it contemplates a good wifi infrastructure (which, as Wyze judged with the timing of the product, is now ubiquitous, premium services not required - no fiber required). Add an SD card and you get PVR per camera. You phone is the hub (where you see all cameras and their recordings). Remote access included (as long as you can connect your phone to the internet; which in no longer the premium service it once was either). Add a back-up power supply for your home and all cameras (and PVR’s) will continue to operate and all that you will lose is remote access. If you want remote access add cellular backup internet connection (and hope the power failure does not affect the cellphone towers (they are supposed to have their own UPS). So same additional stuff required whether you have a wired security system or a wireless system. My experience, at least for a <15 sensor (camera or smartsense device) system Wyze system is way cheaper than the least expensive wired system (Reolink with POE and QNAP NAS) and is almost as easy to manage. Note Wired system still needs wifi to view cameras unless you invest in dedicated monitors or TV’s. All need power, and wifi and internet to work anywhere close to full functionality. WyZe is a great product because it offers great value in function, but like a Tesla does require a decent road to travel on; I can’t see how that an be considered a bad thing.

For me the purchase decision for the Wyze cam was NOT based on the people detection function or Wyze’s affiliation with Xnor.ai, that was always a bonus, add-on feature that I was not expecting at this price point.

For me it was these two standout items:
First, low-cost of the Wyzecam and its amazing hardware for $20. I could have a low-cost solution to purchase large amount of cameras for redundancy allowing for multiple viewing angles around the exterior of my homes.

Second, at the time Wyze was developing the Wyze Maxdrive, which was a genius business plan for its next product - another outstanding differentiator for an upstart company in a market place saturated with home automation clones, that I thought would be the foundation for a long term cost-effective solution for people who wanted a no-monthly fee wireless system, with little or no external data flow to the internet.

But that’s just my thoughts.

It might not have been for you and many other dipping their feet into low cost surveillance but it is the holy grail of the software - No human detection and no false positives on the computer detection (as I am sure WyZe were well aware of). It comes down to the old rule in computing - pick your software before you pick the hardware. Wyze needed to get the cash flow going and sell cameras (the hardware) but knew full well that without the software they would not sell many after the initial buy and try phase. Wyze spent, and continue to spend most of their efforts on the software, and it becomes the real reason people continue to buy and recommend their hardware; again a fact that they are well aware off (its true of all cameras sold before them). You might have bought the camera because of the hardware but you will continue to use the hardware because of the software - just saying.

I would definitely would pay more than $250 per residential camera for that type of functionally if I needed that, plus a subscription fee. The cameras I sell to commercial, institutions and the government are $8,000 to $32,000 each, with a server, ups, with a subscription monthly subscription fee, service contract to match the price, plus labor at the standard US competitive pricing.

One more thing, zulu, just because you commented about software, I have stopped updating the firmware and the iOS application, for all the issues that people have been posting about - care free reliability is important to me. I do want to go back one version of the iOS application before it got updated.

There was an old 90’s TV show about this great car with all its ablitites.

But then they took it too far with the enhancements/upgrades for me.

Just saying

You nailed the #1 most important issue in my entire Wyze universe. Great example invoking KITT :smile:

I feel like I had set everything up perfectly earlier in the year only to have it all blown to bits (repeatedly) by wonky firmware & software changes - in “super pursuit mode” of less valuable features/concerns (to me) - with questionable tactics, implementation strategy, and results… VigorousDelectableElk-size_restricted

Consistent reliability feels like it slipped to a “secondary” tier concern (pun intended) in favor of going gadgety; and it’s all been a giant hasselhoff… :joy:

david_hasselhoff_k2000_kitt

…which discourages further investment into an increasingly wobbly platform.

Instead of waisting time and effort on locks they should fix the lag issues, the connection issues and let people choose their own cloud solution !

They’re not mutually exclusive. Why do you think new products are a “waste”? :slight_smile:

Before i roll out a new product i should take more care and make it my priority in making the older products work well without silly bugs, Will the people that buy the locks come back to the forum next year cos they can’t open a door bacause of connection issues?? ???

Unlike the camera, it doesn’t rely solely on WiFi, and you can still use it without needing to connect to the server (though you obviously wouldn’t be able to lock/unlock remotely without this) From the Wyze Lock FAQ:

What happens if my WiFi goes out?

If your home WiFi goes out you won’t be able to remotely lock or unlock Wyze Lock, but you won’t be locked out! Wyze Lock uses Bluetooth when you’re near the door so you can always get in… even if your home’s WiFi or power are out.

Besides that, the lock doesn’t prevent your normal key usage.

I know that mate, i was just saying, what i’m trying to say is that before you roll out other stuff fix the older stuff, simple and to the point !

I hear you. They just have entirely different teams that work on new products, cloud architecture, app design, etc. Ceasing innovation on new products wouldn’t really expedite fixing issues or adding new features to old products.

Alexa is kinda buggy at times, for example, but it wouldn’t make a lot of sense to say “Amazon should stop Prime service until Alexa works perfectly!”

The Wyzecams did hit a run with zero issues a few months ago. It ran well and very predictable. Unfortunately, many kept asking for too much free add-on features and now the $20 device is what it is.

Yes, that’s right, the camera was working fine when it was doing what its basically capable of: capturing and streaming/recording video. The first main problem was expanding the storage where the RTSP came in. Then I thought that the development would practically continues on elimination of bugs, hardening and stabilization of the firmware.

Please Wyze… please continue to develop the RTSP firmware, because for most of us that’s using the camera for surveillance, its still better to capture everything 24/7 on NAS/NVR, because investigation wise, I still prefer human eyes to decide who’s to capture or not. We just need stable and reliable recording, no other bells and whistle features that could just hinder that basic operation.

Since this thread is about Person Detection (PD) I’m going to stay out of

for the most part. But YOUR priority and MY priority and many others priorities may not be the same.
BUT when I first started amassing my fleet of V2’s & Pans in April '19:
playback was much more of a pain - now we have jump to event
We couldn’t filter events - now we can
cloud storage was extremely limited - now we have CMC
RTSP was non-existent - now I’ve got 2 cams dedicated to RTSP
Cams would drop offline and need physical power cycling

I had no lag issues early on, had great lag issues on older Android build and that got fixed, I’ve virtually no killer connection issues with my cams, with RTSP I am my cloud.

PD was great for me, I’ve 2 cams over 800 miles away plagued by spider webs.
If Wyze can bring back PD I will appreciate it, I’d also appreciate a Wyze NAS and sharks with lasers for a cam defense option.

Yes they will and Wyze will probably make a great effort to fix the issue.
/edited for typo of April '09 changed to April '19

before you reply to a post read and understand the sense and meaning, NOT my personal “priority” ,IT was aiming at the product

!!
Did you read the post?? who cares if you want sharks and love spiders??

Wow, talk about O.G.! Your collection of Wyze cams is impressive, but not as impressive as your time machine! :wink: Haha

Dibs on beta testing for Wyze Flux Capacitor. :laughing: